When I ended my relationship with my son’s father, I was nineteen years old. I had spent the last five years of my life learning to be a “girlfriend” and not a “human” or a “functional part of society”. Literally all of my teenage years were spent in this unhealthy, manipulative union with a guy who was not super concerned with things like monogamy or respect or like, the law, but super concerned with things like getting it in. SO, freshman year of college was not great. I did a lot of soul searching, and by that I mean I wore a lot of black eyeliner. Really though, I was itching to be in a relationship again, since that’s really all my post-pubescent identity had ever consisted of.
Even before my teenage years, my idea of a relationship was kind of skewed. I got the progression of meet, fall in love, get married, have babies down pretty well, but I missed other vital stops along the way, like become friends, disagree about things, appreciate your differences, get a plant, maybe be old enough to have a drivers license before you do any of this, etc. See, my parents met as kids. My mom’s brother Bob was best friends with my dad, so Bob and Mike would work on cars together and my mom would bring them lemonade in the summer and hot chocolate in the winter and so they got married. The end. I’m sure a lot of other stuff happened, but I never heard about any of that. My dad would call my mom on Wednesdays and they’d go out on Fridays. They did this throughout high school and college and then got married immediately after and lived happily ever after and had a boatload of kids and never fought and really love each other a lot. So I thought that was how it worked, and thirteen year old me decided I was ready to make that kind of decision, and so five years later I was like, wait, shit.
So here’s nineteen year old me. Studying English in college, planning to be an English teacher because I decided I wasn’t good enough at music to be a music teacher. Not a lot of direction. Also a teenage mother, so not really doing great at things like relaxing and “going with the flow.” Really I just wanted to find that person and get this show on the road so we could settle down. Also, I spent the last five years not only learning to be a girlfriend but learning to be a girlfriend to specific person, so I didn’t know who I was or what I wanted, but you know, I was pretty flexible on that. (spoiler alert, not recipe for good decision making)
So I get my first post-babydaddy boyfriend. I told my mom I met him through a friend but really I met him on a dating website because I have no social skills or confidence. (Somebody I knew knew somebody he knew so this made it okay.) I meet up with him IRL with a hoard of my friends. He is accompanied by a hoard of his friends. We merge friends, and I spend the next few months with this new ska-loving revolt-against-society lifestyle. These things had been a small part of my identity before, but being with this boy magnified them in me. I also decided that some other parts of my identity were less important, like maybe washing my hair and wanting a career. These philosophies are by no means bad, but they were bad for me because they weren’t mine. They were spoon-fed to me by well meaning friends and cute boys.
So that ends. I could not consistently act like a bad-ass for very long. I wanted to wait until the man lit up on the sign before I crossed the street and I did not have the social or physical endurance required to go to Ska shows. I broke up with him, and we were cool, and then he had a new girlfriend like three days later. But whatever, I’m not bitter or anything.
So a bunch of time passed. I’m not going to pretend I remember how long because it was college and everything is a blur. I hung out with my friends and had “crushes” on boys and started getting into some stuff I really liked like epistemology and behaviorism and beer. I had a handful on crushes on boys from philosophy club because they were smart and outspoken and that was hot. (Right direction, yay!) But at this point, my logical thought patters started to govern every part of my life. I was learning about different types of motivation, and that all behavior has motivation and that EVERYTHING IS SCIENCE. I also changed my major: Psychology with a specialization in Behavior Services and a minor in Philosophy. I populated my schedule with classes entirely devoted to explaining why people do stuff. So naturally, at this point I was totally making all these great well-calculated decisions.
Just kidding. I was making shitty well-calculated decisions.
If you’ve ever learned about Utilitarianism, you probably know that the thing about making good decisions is that they should do more good than harm. This makes sense except that it doesn’t. If a decision about my life makes everyone I know happy except me, then it’s a bad decision. But, ya know. Who didn’t go through the strictly-adhering-to-my-favorite-philosopher’s-guidelines phase in college, am I right?
So utilitarianism. I made up this list (lists!) for how I should choose someone to marry. (Yes, marry. We play to win here.) On it were things like he should be studying psychology, he should have the you’re/your distinction down, he should be taller than me, he should be looking to move into suburban New Jersey get an advanced degree in psychology (PsyD ?) and have lots of babies and settle down and be Catholic so my parents will be cool with him and be nerdy like me and also be a really good kisser. So every little girl’s dream.
I met this guy at open mic night. He was not singing and neither was I (phew). He was there with a friend of mine, and we talked about Star Trek, so I mean this was going to happen. We dated for a couple awkward months. See, he fit my criteria pretty well. He was seven years older than me which I decided meant that he was more mature and closer to settling down. He studied psychology and was super nerdy. Like, we spend a lot of time playing Magic the Gathering at game shops. But apparently you can’t calculate love, and it got really awful really quick. So tears, lots of sitting in cars, lots of ice cream eaten about that.
After that, I still maintained by list, but I added to it that I had to feel good about the decision. The thing about science is that you have to be super objective about stuff, and “feel good” is like, the most subjective thing ever. So I decided that I felt good about whatever I decided I felt good about, because who knows anyway. I met someone awesome. He was studying Psychology and he talked to me about Psychology and pff, no brainer. And he was really handsome, but PSYCHOLOGY SCIENCE OK. At first we dated a little and then we stopped dating and then we started dating again and then we had a history of friendship so it seemed to be going swimmingly. My parents thought he was great, he fit in with my family great, he loved my son, everything was great. But it was still calculated. We dated for over a year. I loved him very much, and I still do, but we wanted different things and we communicated terribly. We stayed together even when it was glaringly obvious that we weren’t happy because it made so much sense to be together.
So here’s my point. It doesn’t make sense. You can’t calculate it. You can’t have criteria. You can’t decide to be in love. You can’t decide how you feel. You can’t decide who you are. You just have to live, and find out along the way.